October 17, 2019
No items found.

Discrimination Lawsuit Proceeds Despite Arbitration Clause

Plaintiffs bringing a class action lawsuit against Avon for denying their rights to breast pump have been allowed to continue in court rather than in arbitration.

 Avon was unsuccessful in arguing that the claims of discrimination should be decided in an arbitration. Plaintiff Caroline Ruiz asserts that when she was hired by Avon in November, she signed an employment agreement and a mandatory arbitration clause.  After a delayed start, Ms. Ruiz requested and signed a new Employment Agreement in December, which states that the forum for legal disputes is in New York courts, and no new mandatory arbitration clause. Avon claims that the original Employment Agreement, signed in November, and the mandatory arbitration clause also signed in November, control because the only material difference between the two Employment Agreements is the start date. A federal judge ruled that, pursuant to well-established New York law, a subsequent contract regarding the same matter will supersede the prior contract. Barnum v. Millbrook Care , 850 F. Supp. 1227, 1236 (S.D.N.Y. 1994). Therefore, the December Employment Agreement supersedes the arbitration agreement signed in November, and the lawsuit against Avon continues, although class certification has not yet been decided.

The New York State Legislature recently reformed the State Human Rights Law, expanding the prohibition of mandatory arbitration clauses from sexual harassment claims (passed in 2018) to all discrimination claims. This law goes into effect on October 11, 2019, and all employment contracts drafted after that date must comply with this provision. Still, the applicability of arbitration clauses continues to be heavily litigated.

Written by Law Clerk Emily Entwistle

white line

Federal Family and Sick Leave for Covid-19 Expanded by New York District Court

August 14, 2020
Leave
Paid Family Leave
Pregnancy Discrimination
FMLA
S.D.N.Y. Judge Paul Oetken invalidated parts of the Department of Labor’s interpretation of the Families First Coronavirus Response Act in a lawsuit brought by New York State Attorney General Letitia James.

The First Recession for Women

August 11, 2020
Gender Discrimination
There is a new feature to the pandemic-induced recession that has decimated employment, manufacturing, child care, education, and just about every other facet of life. It is women, not men who are the most greatly affected by the force of the shutdown.

New York State Human Rights Law Invoked in Sexual Harassment Arbitration Case

August 11, 2020
Sexual Harassment
A split has appeared in how to handle sexual harassment cases with a New York trial judge ruling recently that the state’s Human Rights Law prevents companies and employees from entering arbitration over sexual harassment. This contradicts an earlier ruling in New York’s Southern District where a judge ruled that arbitration under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) supersedes New York’s statutory prohibition against arbitration.

Get In Touch

Knowing where to turn in legal matters can make a big difference. Contact our employment lawyers to determine if we can help you.