April 22, 2020
No items found.

What’s Next? As States Look to Reopen, Technology Looms

As coronavirus continues to rage throughout the world, many experts are starting to speculate on when and how to loosen federal, state and municipal restrictions on movement and business. There is near unanimous consensus that a vaccine is months, if not years, in the future, and this belief raises the necessity of states and municipalities to develop a robust contact tracing system that can quickly address the inevitable flare ups of the virus, which will allow public health officials to deploy targeted quarantines that will allow the surrounding community to maintain some semblance of normalcy.

Enter tech giants Apple and Google. Both companies are proposing a joint effort to develop contact-tracing capabilities via smartphones that run their operating systems. The short version of the companies' proposal works like this: Android and iOS users would opt in to a contact-tracing app that relies on GPS data from users’ phones. If, for example, a user is diagnosed with coronavirus, the app will be designed to contact other people who have been in close proximity to that individual. As of this writing, the proposal assures that users would be anonymized and that movement and other personal data would not be collected by Apple or Google.

The proposal is similar to programs that are currently being proposed by or used in other countries, such as Israel, which passed emergency measures authorizing its security forces to use mobile data to assist in contact tracing efforts. EU officials have called for a similar program to the one proposed by Apple and Google.

While there is no question that technology, especially mobile technology, will have a large part to play in speeding response times and providing fast and accurate information about coronavirus outbreaks, there is significant potential for problems that must be considered, ranging from mundane technical issues like how stringent the algorithm should be when contacting people to much broader issues, such as unequal access to stable internet and the potential to trample civil liberties. 

The ACLU, for example, has already weighed in, noting that, in theory the idea is a good one, but that the developers and the governments that will inevitably use the technology must prove that they properly protect people’s rights. Additionally, the technology relies on people both opting in and respecting the system enough not to abuse it by making false reports or pretending to be someone else.

Another major issue we are tracking is the one of anonymity. Although representatives of Google and Apple have assured that their efforts will effectively anonymize user data, as The Markup noted, tying user data to public health records will make anonymity more difficult and there is great potential for users to be reidentified.

We will continue to watch how developments unfold and how this may affect you.

white line

Reopening to Require Significant Adjustments to Ensure Worker Safety

May 6, 2020
No items found.
As US states begin to ease their shelter-in-place and lockdown orders, we are fast realizing, like other countries, that shutting down normal operations is much simpler than restarting them. Unlike sheltering in place, a return to public life is going to require significant resources and policies in place to curb potential for future outbreaks and ensure that workers and the public are safe when they go out.

Coronavirus and the Future of Childcare

April 30, 2020
Gender Discrimination
Pregnancy Discrimination
Mounting research demonstrates that child care providers are facing a serious crisis, which will have long term implications for women’s rights and the workforce.

COVID-19 testing and Anti-Discrimination Law

April 28, 2020
No items found.
“Immunity passports”? “Antibody certificates”? As countries around the world consider widespread antibody or immunity testing as a precondition for normal, non-distanced life, many raise the prospect of “second class citizenship” based on COVID-19 immunity.

Get In Touch

Knowing where to turn in legal matters can make a big difference. Contact our employment lawyers to determine if we can help you.