August 11, 2020

New York State Human Rights Law Invoked in Sexual Harassment Arbitration Case

A split has appeared in how to handle sexual harassment cases with a New York trial judge ruling recently that the state’s Human Rights Law prevents companies and employees from entering arbitration over sexual harassment. This contradicts an earlier ruling in New York’s Southern District where a judge ruled that arbitration under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) supersedes New York’s statutory prohibition against arbitration. 

There is a useful summary of the most recent decision at Mintz, but the quick takeaways are that when statutory law changed in 2018, which allowed plaintiffs to seek relief in court rather than through arbitration, employers, even those who had previous employment agreements that stipulated arbitration, were arguably no longer able to seek arbitration under the FAA laws; furthermore, the judge argued that any mandatory arbitration clauses were invalidated by the new state law. 

Confounding matters further, in February another trial judge in New York ruled that changes in the law do not invalidate previous arbitration agreements. At the moment, it remains unclear whether employers’ mandatory arbitration clauses regarding sexual harassment complaints are valid any longer. As there are sure to be appeals, this is a case we will be watching.

white line

Meet Berke-Weiss Law's 2025 Summer Law Clerks

June 17, 2025
No items found.
2025 Summer Law Clerks have started their summer intership with the Berke-Weiss Law team!

The Supreme Court Opinion in Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services and its Impact on Title VII Discrimination Suits

June 10, 2025
Gender Discrimination
Race Discrimination
A recent Supreme Court decision could have an impact on future Title VII Discrimination Suits.

Berke-Weiss Law Says Goodbye to Their Wonderful 2024-2025 Student Law Clerk!

April 24, 2025
No items found.
The Firm wishes Eileen Farrell well in her future endeavors and thanks her for all her hard work at the Firm.

Get In Touch

Knowing where to turn in legal matters can make a big difference. Contact our employment lawyers to determine if we can help you.